Pet insurance plans with "no limits" may sound attractive. But are they worth the cost? There are a few things to consider.

Typically, with any type of insurance, the more coverage you buy, the more expensive it's going to be. To get "unlimited" pet insurance coverage, you may need to pay an expensive premium or select a high deductible to bring down the cost. Both options could have an impact on the value of the plan.

ASPCA Pet Health Insurance plans are designed to set reasonable limits so customers have the coverage they need while keeping the plans as affordable as possible. In fact, only about 0.5% of our customers even hit their plan's coverage limit.+ Would a more expensive plan be worth the extra cost?

Here’s an example: Jill is a 9-year-old cat who got sick twice in a year.

In this case, Jill's pet parent decided to increase her deductible to get a premium she could afford. The cost is the same as a Level 2 ASPCA Pet Health Insurance plan, but the higher incident deductible on the other plan has an impact on her reimbursements.

 logo.pngtrupanion.png
No Limits
Monthly Cost $30.70 $30.69
Deductible Option
Required for Comparable Plan Cost
$100 per year $395 per incident
  Illness 1 Illness 2 Illness 1 Illness 2
Total Treatment costs $1,582 $2,316 $1,582 $2,316
Excluded Exam Fees $0 $0 $147 $347
Deductible $100
per year
$0 $395
per incident
$395
Potential payout after deductible* $1,247 $1,936 $936 $1,417
Total potential payout based on 90% of usual
and customary covered charges
based on 90% of vet bill minus exam fees
Total Reimbursement for 2 Illnesses $3,183 $2,353

Here Jill's parent chose to pay more in premiums to maximize her reimbursements. The premium for the "unlimited" plan is about 30% higher than the ASPCA Pet Health Insurance Level 2 plan, but the incident deductible and other exclusions still affect the "no limit" payout.

 logo.pngtrupanion.png
No Limits
Monthly Cost $30.70 $39.79
Deductible Option
Required for Comparable Plan Cost
$100 per year $100 per incident
  Illness 1 Illness 2 Illness 1 Illness 2
Total Treatment costs $1,582 $2,316 $1,582 $2,316
Excluded Exam Fees $0 $0 $147 $347
Deductible $100
per year
$0 $100
per incident
$100
Potential payout after deductible* $1,247 $1,936 $1,202 $1,682
Total potential payout based on 90% of usual
and customary covered charges
based on 90% of vet bill minus exam fees
Total Reimbursement for 2 Illnesses $3,183 $2,884
Total annual premium paid $368 $477

* Potential reimbursements shown are calculated as if they occurred to the same 9-year-old domestic longhair cat in zip 68137. Calculations based on actual ASPCA Pet Health Insurance claims received for this pet and on publicly available policy information as of 4/21/14. Coverage and reimbursement for these types of claims are not to be inferred but is determined in reference to a particular insurance plan, as well as the fact and circumstance of each claim.

+Internal claims data, Feb. 2014

Comparison information is provided using publicly available information as of 10/28/13 and is only meant to summarize program features, not a specific plan. Review each provider's plan terms for more details. The descriptions of other providers' plans were not provided by that company. If you have questions about other plans, please contact an agent of that company. It is our intention to provide fair and accurate comparison information. Although we attempt to keep information up to date, it may change from time to time. If you are aware of any inaccuracies or changes in the information provided, let us know by emailing socialmedia@hartvillegroup.com or mailing Marketing Department 3840 Greentree Avenue SW, Canton, Ohio 44706.